By Stephanie Younger •
10 days ago, I climbed up the Robert E. Lee Statue at a protest in Richmond, Virginia—the former capital of the Confederacy—and I was asked to speak. This was unplanned, and I have been grieving so heavily these past few weeks that I had no idea what to speak about at first. I began by reading an excerpt from Dr. Martin Luther King’s “Letter From a Birmingham Jail” (the part where he said that he is “gravely disappointed with the white moderate”). Then, I delivered a brief, extemporaneous speech about the growth of these white liberals’ co-optation of anti-racism, and our grief.
Are these so-called “well-intentioned” white liberals finding themselves just now speaking up about racism? Or, do they often find themselves solely speaking up after police murders? I am livid about the eerie silence and deadly complacency of these so-called “well-intentioned” white liberals in light of the recent police murders of Black life. White liberals must extend their solidarity beyond changing their profile picture or attending protests for a photo op. To follow up from my previous article, let’s unpack the recent growth of co-optation of the fight for Black lives.
The Show Must Be Paused was originally created by two Black women named Jamila Thomas and Briana Agyemeng. On their website, they stated,
“Tuesday, June 2nd is meant to intentionally disrupt the work week. Monday suggests a long weekend and we can’t wait until Friday for change. It is a day to take a beat for an honest, reflective and productive conversation about what actions we need to collectively take to support the Black community.”#TheShowMustBePaused
The day before the protest at the Lee Statue – Tuesday, June 2nd – The Show Must Be Paused and its mission was co-opted and called, “Blackout Tuesday.” Tens of millions of Instagram users, many of which are comprised of white people and non-Black people of color, posted a black square on their profiles “in solidarity with the Black community.” A few of these users were so-called “well-intentioned” white liberals that I previously knew. Quite a few of them unfriended, unfollowed and blocked me on social media for speaking out and taking action against anti-Black racism, years prior to the current uprisings. Many of the white liberals I knew who participated in so-called “Blackout Tuesday” have suppressed my voice as a Black girl by labeling me with stereotypes rooted in misogynoir. Those who have been apathetic towards the long fight for Black lives seemingly remained silent until recently, when being “down” for Black lives was seen as a trend. These were also white liberals who have silenced me and told me to my face that what I do isn’t real activism, while being praised for co-opting experiences that they don’t carry and movements that aren’t about them. I am especially infuriated with the fact that white liberals are co-opting anti-racism in a way that is self-serving, and garners the support that we need; many of us who experience first-hand what the so-called “well-intentioned” white liberals do to us behind closed doors.
Instead of actively disrupting the systems that allow Black people to be murdered by the state, white liberals disrupt our grief, by tokenizing Black girls, and demanding that we “educate them.” On top of white liberals using me as an accessory so they can feel good about themselves for “including a Black girl,” white liberals insulted my intelligence by assuring me that they don’t need to put in anymore effort than they think they already have to be anti-racist—doing so while being disingenuous to the resources that are available to them in plain sight. More often than ever, I’ve personally been asked to do intellectual and emotional labor for stuff that white liberals can search on Google. When white liberals who depend on every Black woman they come across to “educate” them on how to not oppress us, they show that they view individual Black girls as a spokesperson for our communities. Black girls are not “teachable moments,” and we especially deserve so much better than being used as self-serving accessories for organizations to appear “more diverse,” and for the white liberals who feel as though they are “the exception.”
While the state continues to criminalize and incarcerate, and murder Black women who take action against anti-Black racism, white liberals are being praised for mimicking ideas, concepts and theory that they have stolen from us. While white liberals have used our trauma, our creativity, our bodies to make their businesses, corporations, and their organizations appear “more diverse” to gain capital, they accuse us of “attacking” them when we challenge their intentions. When we identify the very little respect these so-called “well-intentioned” white liberals have for Black women, specifically through the ways they have appropriated our language and our ideas, they silence us. When the press, their followers on Facebook and Instagram aren’t watching, they label us as “jealous,” “shady,” “angry,” and “aggressive” to invalidate our grievances. I noticed that many spend far more time centering their own concerns about being excluded by co-workers, classmates and family members who outwardly hate us, and less time holding them accountable.
White liberals have co-opted anti-racism in a way that is palatable and self-serving, which is an obstacle to our liberation. Despite white liberals’ certainty that they are somehow “the exception,” basing it on their claims that they “have Black friends” and “vote blue,” we will not be deterred from our callings to act on their claims that they practice anti-racism. White liberals patting themselves on the back for saying “racism is wrong,” and thinking to themselves, “that’s enough activism for today” after posting a Black square will not deter us from fighting for our liberation.
The questions white liberals should be asking themselves and each other is,
“What does your solidarity look like after posting a black square on Instagram?”
“Are you willing to practice anti-racism by showing up for Black lives and holding yourself and other white people accountable?”
“How are you going to accomplice yourselves with the fight for Black liberation?”3 Questions I asked in “A Call-to-Action to ‘Well-Intentioned’ White Liberals” at the protest on June 3rd, 2020
White liberals should spend less time occupying Black folks’ spaces to claim that they’re “anti-racist allies,” while policing the way we exercise our right to dissent; and more time applying anti-racism to their lives, by holding themselves and other white people accountable for perpetuating anti-Black racism, regardless of their intentions; And that’s the bare minimum.
Stephanie Younger is an 18-year-old based in Richmond, Virginia, whose work centers the intersections Black feminism and womanism have with prison and police abolition.